A 54-year-old Woman with
Kun H uang MD PHD, Robin Pa rker MD FRCPC, Tabassum Fi roz M D FRCPC
Huang Parker Firoz
About the Authors
Kun Huang was the chief medical resident at the Royal Columbian Hospital and is now PGY-4 in rheumatology at the University of British Columbia. Tabassum Firoz is an obstetric internist focusing on medical complications in pregnancy and the link to postpartum health. In addition, she practices as a general internist.Globally, her research is focused on maternal morbidity and mortality, and locally on and pre-eclampsia and postpartum cardiovascular risk reduction. Robin L. Parker is an anatomic pathologist, with special interest in gynecological pathology, at Abbotsford Regional Hospital & Cancer Centre in British Columbia. Correspondence may be directed to email@example.com
Paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration (PCD) is a rare but devastating syndrome associated with autoantibodies targeting cerebellar antigens expressed by tumours outside of nervous system. PCD is most often associated with breast and gynecological cancers and can precede clinical manifestations of the cancer. Of the dozen autoantibodies associated with PCD, anti-Yo is the most commonly identified In this report, we present a case of a woman with progressive cerebellar ataxia and anti-Yo antibody,who has microscopic high-grade serous carcinoma found with empiric total abdominal hysterectomy bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy (TAH-BSO). This case highlights the challenges in diagnosis, difficulty in identifying the occult malignancy, and the need for multidisciplinary collaboration between Internal Medicine, Neurology, Gynecology and Pathology.The literature relating to diagnosis, prognosis and treatment of PCD is also reviewed.
L'ataxie cerebelleuse paraneoplasique (ou PCD pour paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration) est un syndrome rare mais foudroyant, associe ala presence d'autoanticorps qui ciblent les antigenes cerebelleux et qui ont pour origine des tumeurs localisees a l'exterieur du systeme nerveux. Le PCD est la plupart du temps associe a des cancers du sein ou gynecologiques et peut preceder les manifestations cliniques du cancer. Parmi la dizaine d'autoanticorps associes au PCD, l'anti-Yo est le plus frequent. Dans ce rapport, nous decrivons le cas d'une femme presentant une ataxie cerebelleuse et des autoanticorps anti-Yo. Celle-ci est atteinte d'un carcinome sereux microscopique de haut grade, decouvert ala suite d'une hysterectomie abdominale complete et d'unesalpingo-ovariectomie bilaterale (ou TAH-BSO pour Total abdominal hysterectomy bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy). Ce cas fait ressortir les problemes d'etablissement de diagnostic et de detection de tumeur maligne occulte, ainsi que la necessite d'une collaboration multidisciplinaire entre professionnels de medecine interne, neurologie, gynecologie et pathologie. Nous faisons egalement le point sur la documentation relative au diagnostic, au pronostic et au traitement duPCD.
18 Vo lume 11 , I ssue 3 , 2016 Canadia n Journal of Gene r a l Int e r n al Medicin e
Huang et al.
A previously healthy 54-year-old Caucasian female presented with a six-week history of progressively worsening ataxia, dysarthria and involuntary movement of her limbs.She denied other neurological symptoms including vertigo, diplopia, or motor or sensory changes. Memory and comprehension were unaffected. She denied constitutional symptoms and had no personal history of malignancy. Her only medication was escitalopram for anxiety. Family history was unremarkable. She was a non-smoker and drank alcohol only occasionally.
Physical examination was remarkable for truncal ataxia, bilateral dysmetria, dysdiadochokinesia, ataxic dysarthria, saccades, diplopia and tibubation.She did not have nystagmus. Cranial nerves, motor exam, reflexes, proprioception and sensation were intact. Initial blood work including complete blood counts, electrolytes, renal function, liver enzymes,
Hemoglobin Alc,serum Venereal Disease Research Laboratory
left breast nodules and a left adrenal nodule measuring less than O.Scm. The ovaries and uterus were normal. Designated adrenal CT confirmed that the left adrenal gland nodule was in keeping with an adenoma breast ultrasound and mammogram were unremarkable. Fecal occult blood testing, cancer antigen 19-9 (CA19-9), carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA), CA125, Alpha fetal protein (AFP), serum protein electrophoresis (SPEP) and urine protein electrophoresis (UPEP) were all within normal limits. Whole-body positron emission tomography (PET) revealed normall8F-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) uptake.
The CSF was sent to Dr. Marvin Fritzler's Mitogen lab in Calgary for analysis ofPCD antibody panel. PCD panel results came back positive for high titre of anti-Yo antibody and all other antibodies were negative.
Since anti-Yo antibody primarily occurs in patients with PCD who have cancers of the breast, ovary, endometrium or fallopian tubes, upon discussion with gynecology and the
test ( VORL), rapid plasma regain (RPR), vitamin B
thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) were all normal.
patient and her family, the decision was made to empirically perform total abdominal hysterectomy bilateral salpingo
Her presentation supported subacute cerebellar ataxia. Extensive work up was performed. Initial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the head was unremarkable. cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) fluid revealed normal white blood, elevated total protein at 685 mg/L, and IgG at 138 mg!L with oligoclonal pattern consistent with an inflammatory or immune process. CSF was negative for syphilis, bacteria, fungus or viruses. A repeat MRI head to specifically look for signs of Creutzfeldt Jakob disease was also negative. Rheumatologic work up including anti-nuclear antibody (ANA), extracted nuclear antibody (ENA), rheumatoid factor (RF), anti-neutriphil cytoplasmic antibody (ANCA) were negative.
Further search in malignancy was carried out. Computed
tomography (CT) chest, abdomen and pelvis showed two small
oophorectomy (TAH-BSO). While the surgical specimen was grossly normal, histologic examination revealed microscopic foci of high-grade serous carcinoma in both ovaries, and intraepithelial (in situ) and invasive serous carcinoma of the left fallopian tube. (Figure 1) The final diagnosis was PCD secondary to bilateral ovarian serous carcinoma.
During the investigations, the patient was treated with two cycles of IVIG for suspected PCD with no neurological improvement. Despite of tumour removal and ongoing physical rehabilitation, patient continued to deteriorate neurologically. At the time of submission of this case report, the patient was completely bed bound. She was unable to speak, write or carry on activity of daily living due to severe truncal and appendicular ataxia.
Figure 1.Histology revealed occult foci of serous carcinoma (hematoxylin-eosin,200x).(A) Surface ovarian involvement by high-grade serous carcinoma
(arrows).(B) Serous tubalintraepithelialcarcinoma.
Canadian Journal of Ge neral I nter n a l M ed i cine V olum e 11, Is sue 3, 2016 33
A 54-Year-Old Woman with Progressive Ataxia
It is believed that PNS are immune-mediated processes in which autoantibodies against tumour antigen cross the blood brain barrier and mediate neuronal degeneration. Ovarian tumors have high potential to mount an immune response since anti-ovarian autoantibodies are frequently found in patients affected with these neoplasms.1 Table 1 summarizes the common paraneoplastic autoantibodies identified in PCD. Among these, anti-Yo and anti-Tr antibodies are predominantly associated with cerebellar dysfunction whereas other autoantibodies involve other areas of the central nervous system.
The target antigen of anti-Yo antibody (also called Purkinje cell antibody type 1or PCA-1) is the cdr protein that is expressed by ovarian and breast cancers as well as the cerebellar Purkinje cells. As a result, anti-Yo antibody cross-reacts with Purkinje cells and causes degeneration. It is identified in the serum of up to 70% of the patients with PCD and carries a specificity of nearly 100% for the diagnosis of an underlying breast or gynaecological malignancy.2-4 It can be rarely associated with small cell lung cancer.5 Most patients (60 to 70%) with PCD do not have a cancer diagnosis at the onset of their neurologic symptoms.1 2
Patients with PCD typically present with subacute cerebellar fmdings including downbeat nystagmus, saccades, limb and truncal ataxia, dysarthria, and dysphagia. As the diagnosis is often very challenging and delayed, symptoms typically continue to worsen for weeks or months to the point of severe disability. At the time of PCD diagnosis, more than
Table 1. Common autoantibodies associated with PCD
50% of patients with anti-Yo antibodies are unable to walk and have more functional disability than patients with other autoantibodies. Our patient was bed-bound and unable to care for herself or communicate by 12 weeks of presentation.
The PNS Euro network has recommended a set of diagnostic criteria to distinguish "definite" from "possible" PNS depending on the presence of classical or non-classical neurological syndromes, presence of distinct antibodies, presence of a tumour, and improvement of symptoms after cancer therapy.6 To apply the diagnostic criteria to clinical practice, steps in the diagnosis of PCD include: 1) ruling out other causes of cerebellar ataxia; 2) confirming paraneoplastic phenomenon with CSF autoantibody analysis;and 3) searching for the underlying malignancy.
Mitogen laboratory in Calgary, founded by Dr. Marvin Fritzler, is the only Canadian facility to specialize in novel autoantibodies and biomarkers for autoimmune diseases. In addition to systemic autoimmune rheumatic diseases, Mitogen also researches and identifies autoantibodies associated with idiopathic ataxia and chronic inflammatory demyelinating neuropathy. Detailed panels of diagnostic tests can be found on website (http://rnitogen.ca).
Whole-body CT scan in adjunction with pelvic ultrasound and mammogram are the first line investigations to search for the primary tumour. If no positive findings are seen, whole body FDG-PET can identify a lesion as small as lcm and is reported to have improved the diagnostic rate. Tumour markers including CA19-9, CEA, CA125 and AFP are often ordered although the yield is limited.
Occult malignancy in PCD is not uncommon. In a small case series, Hetzel et al found seven of the 19 patients with
both ovarian cancer and PCD had no tumour symptoms or
Anti-Yo Anti-Hu Anti-Tr Anti-CV2
Anti-VGCC (P/Q type) Anti-SOX1
small cell lung carcinoma (SCLC) Hodgkin's disease
Breast. gynecologic cancers,and SCLC Testicle, Lung
SCLC SCLC SCLC
abnormal imaging prior to surgery.7 The decision for surgical resection was made exclusively based on the detection of autoantibodies. All these patients had high-grade ovarian adenocarcinoma on histology. We took a similar approach with our patient.
Removal of the tumour is the first line of treatment to prevent disease progression. Unfortunately, eradication of the cancer cells does not usually reverse the neurological damage that is already present. There are no randomized
controlled trials or large case studies in the treatment of
34 Vo lume 11, Issue 3, 2016 Canadian Jo u r na l of Genera l Interna l Medicine
Huang et al.
this disease entity. Anecdotally, there has been neurological improvement in patients tried on various immunological therapies such as IVIG (attempted in our patient without improvement), corticosteroids, plasma exchange, azathioprine, cyclophosphamide and rituximab.8 12 However, in a large case series with SO PCD patients, immunotherapy was not significantly associated with recovery.11 Counseling and rehabilitation are cornerstones of therapy in these patients.
In most patients suffering from PCD, prognosis is determined by the type of antibody rather than the underlying malignancy. The aforementioned retrospective analysis with SO PCD patients demonstrated poor neurological outcome and dismal overall survival, especially for those with detectable anti-Yo and anti-Hu antibodies.11 In this analysis, the five-year survival rate of PCD patients with anti-Yo antibody was less than
2S%.11 Similarly, in the largest case series review from the
PNS Euronetwork database with 979 patients, the clinical course of PCD patients with anti-Yo and anti-Hu was found to be more severe than those with other antibodies.10 The median survival for patients with anti-Yo was 13 months and anti-Hu was seven months. In contrast, median survival for patients withanti-Trwasmore than 113 months andanti-Ri more than
69 months. Mortality was caused by cancer itself in half of the patients with neurological progression being the cause of death in the other half.10
Our case has several practical implications. First, progressive cerebellar ataxia has a broad differential diagnoses and a broad work up should be undertaken. Second, screening of neural autoantibodies is important in order to establish the diagnosis of PCD and to evaluate prognosis. The most common autoantibodies associated with PCD and their respective cancers include anti-Yo (gynecological cancers), anti-Hu (small cell lung carcinoma),and anti-Tr (Hodgkin lymphoma).12 The presence of one of these antibodies in CSF or serum should prompt a search for malignancy. Third, this case report is an
example that neurological symptoms may develop long before
any tumour-related symptoms or radiographic findings. If clinical suspicion of a specific type malignancy is high as in our case, preemptive surgical resection may be warranted. Last but not least, treatment of PNS emphasizes on medical therapy or surgical resection of the underlying malignancy. Immunological therapies have not been shown to have neurological benefits in large case series of PCD patients.
I. Szubert $,Michalak S, Szpurek D, Moszynski R, Krygowska-Zielinska J,
Sajdak S. Anti-ovarian antibodies in sera of patients with ovarian tumors. lmmunol Lett.2012;148(2):133-137. doi:10.1016/j.imlet.2012.09.008.
2. Rojas I, Graus F, Keime-Guibert F, et a!. Long-term clinical outcome of
paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration and anti·Yo antibodies. Neurology.
3. Bradley WH, Dottino PR, Rahaman J. Paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration in ovarian carcinoma: case report with review of immune modulation.
Int J Gynecol Cancer. 2008;18(6):1364-1367.doi:IO.II II/j.1525-
4. Peterson K, Rosenblum MK, Kotanides H, Posner JB.Paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration.I. A clinical analysis of 55 anti Yo antibody-positive patients. Neurology. 1992;42( I 0):1931·1937. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ pubmed/1407575.
5. Bernal F, Shams'iiiS, Rojas I, eta!. Anti-Tr antibodies as markers of
paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration and Hodgkin's disease. Neurology.
6. Graus F, Delattre JY, Antoine JC, eta!.Recommended diagnostic criteria
for paraneoplastic neurological syndromes. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry.
7. Hetzel OJ, Stanhope CR, O'Neill BP, Lennon VA.Gynecologic cancer in patients with subacute cerebellar degeneration predicted by anti Purkinje cell antibodies and limited in metastatic volume. Mayo Clin Proc.
8. Blaes F, Strittmatter M, Merkelbach S, et al. Intravenous immunoglobulins
in the therapy of paraneoplastic neurological disorders.J Neurol.
9. Shams'ili S, de Beukelaar J, Gratama JW, et al. An uncontrolled trial of
rituximab for antibody associated paraneoplastic neurological syndromes. J
NeuroL 2006;253(1):16-20. doi:I0.1007/s00415-005-0882-0.
10. Giometto B, Grisold W, Vitaliani R,eta!. Paraneoplastic neurologic syndrome in the PNS Euronetwork database:a European study from 20 centers. Arch NeuroL 2010;67(3):330-335.doi:IO.IOOI/archneuroL2009.341.
1I. Shams'ili S, Grefkens J, de Leeuw B, eta!. Paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration associated with antineuronal antibodies:analysis of 50 patients. Brain. 2003;126(Pt 6):1409-1418. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ pubmed/12764061.
12. Honnorat J, Cartalat-Carel S. Advances in paraneoplastic neurological
syndromes.Curr Opin Oncol.2004;16(6):614-620. doi:OOOO1622-200411000-
Canadian Journa l of General Internal Medicine Vo l ume 11, I ssue 3, 2016 35
- There are currently no refbacks.